Reviews and Comments

Fionnáin

fionnain@bookwyrm.social

Joined 3 years, 11 months ago

I arrange things into artworks, including paint, wood, plastic, raspberry pi, people, words, dialogues, arduino, sensors, web tech, light and code.

I use words other people have written to help guide these projects, so I read as often as I can. Most of what I read is literature (fiction) or nonfiction on philosophy, art theory, ethics and technology.

Also on Mastodon.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Proxopera (Paperback, 1979, Quartet Books) 4 stars

Obscured by Masks

4 stars

Proxopera is a relentless novella, set in the Troubles in Northern Ireland and told at a furious pace. It is ostansibly about a family held hostage by three IRA members while one of them is told to drive a bomb into the local town.

On a subtler level it speaks to the senselessness of violence, winding and weaving through snippets of old stories remembered by the central character. Brutal, poetic, and sometimes darkly funny, it is a harsh reminder of the violence of the near past in Northern Ireland.

Partners (Paperback, 2016, Center for Humans & Nature) 4 stars

Interspecies Kinship Contributors: Sharon Blackie, Nickole Brown, Brenda Cárdenas, Ourania Emmanouil, Monica Gagliano, Anne Galloway, …

Making Kin with Nonhmans

4 stars

This is the third book in the series Kinship. It is a series of essays and poems, this volume focussed on relationships betqeen human and nonhuman kin. Like the first two, it suffers from a white bias and a US-centric viewpoint in some of the essays, but mostly it contains some wonderful writing and is the best in the series so far.

Standout articles are by the always-brilliant Anne Galloway and her kinship with sheep, Merlin Sheldrake's thoughts on fungi and lichen, and Richard Powers' thoughtful considerations on the degrees of separation between us and other creatures (although that essay also contains one of the series' most damning howlers in reference to the Rwandan genocide). Great, broad essays and a worthwhile book.

Thinking in systems (Paperback, 2009, Earthscan) 2 stars

A clear, thoughtful, and wide-reaching exploration of complex systems, in theory and in practice. Meadows …

System System

2 stars

Donella Meadows is one of the 20th Century's most well known systems theorists, mostly due to her landmark book Limits to Growth. This follow-on, written in the 90s and published in 2006, is a high-level introduction to systems theory.

As a basic book on a subject, it is accessible and sometimes enjoyable. It is strongeSt when Meadows is exploring comcepts like nonlnear systems, where as a reader you can consider the implications. But the book is not well written, and uses far too many examples, sometimes contradictory ones, without useful evidence or theory. While it is refreshing to see a stance in the 90s that supports systemic change, other more recent books do this better.

Also, the unapologetic references to Garrett Hardin are pretty unpalettable to anyone who knows about him.

Data Farms (EBook, 2022, Open Humanities Press) 3 stars

What is at stake in naming data centres as data farms? These installations are essentially …

Data decentred

3 stars

This is a research object presented as a series of essays and musings on data infrastructure in different nations and political regions. It is as much a philosophical dive into the idea of data centres as it is a technical or sociological book. Although the metaphor of 'farms' never really materialises in the text (despite the editor's promises at the beginning), the deeper connections of data to infrastructure and geopolitics make for fascinating and thoughtful reading. The design is also terrific.

Although the chapters are by different authors, the overall voice feels like it is collective and cohesive. There is a tendency for the essays to repeat musings on infrastructure, as there are natural overlaps in different studies, which could have been trimmed out.

Multispecies Storytelling in Intermedial Practices (Paperback, punctum books, Earth, Milky Way) 3 stars

Multispecies Storytelling in Intermedial Practices is a speculative endeavor asking how we may represent, relay, …

Multiple perspectives on Multi-species Storytelling

3 stars

This is a strong collection of essays, poems and artworks by philosophers, poets, academics and artists writing on multispecies storytelling. It includes well-known figures like Vinciane Despret and Helen V. Pritchard alongside others who are newer to the field. The essays are all very different, taking perspectives from rodents, cockroaches, dogs, penguins, fungi and many others in an array of stories.

The diversity of the essays is a strength and a weakness for reading this through, as it is hard to move from one to another fluidly. However, this is not that type of book. It is exploratory and playful. The best moments are in a poetic and fun exploration by Gillian Wylde, an artistic collaboration with cockroaches by Adam Dickinson and a wonderful essay of a journey of learning with cows by Emily McGiffin. Worth a read for anyone interested in this area.

Quarry Wood (2018, Canongate Books) 3 stars

A Life Imagined

3 stars

Nan Shepherd is famous today for her wonderful book exploring the Cairngorm mountains, The Living Mountain. This book, The Quarry Wood, came earlier and is s novel, concerning a protagonist Martha and her life going into university education.

The narrative flows very well, and the dialogue is brilliant, written in part in Scottish phonetic. However, the story doesn't ever really get going, and although it does describe an interesting set of characters and time, I found the book too slow to enjoy fully. It is more a poetic description of a time and place than a novel.

reviewed The Power of Words by Simone Weil

The Power of Words (Paperback, 2020, Penguin Books, Limited) 3 stars

Some Powerful Words

3 stars

Simone Weil is sometimes seen as a contentious philosopher, although I often wonder if that is mostly because she died young in a fraught time. Had her ideas developed, with a broader context, they might have resolved into more complete arguments.

This short compilation of three essays from the 1940s is a good example of her brilliance, her contentiousness and her unresolved ideas. The title essay is a thoughtful deep dive into how power is maintained through language, focussing on the dominant communist-fascist dichotomy of the time. The second essay, Human Personality considers individual and collective personhood, but makes broad claims about individuality that miss glaring counter-arguments that seem obvious, at least in today's philosophies. The third essay, The Needs of the Soul is from Weil's magnum opus, "The Need For Roots", and even in that book it felt unresolved. It deals with how rootedness and moral philosophy are entangled. …

On Earth We're Briefly Gorgeous (Hardcover, 2019, Jonathan Cape) 3 stars

On Earth We’re Briefly Gorgeous is a letter from a son to a mother who …

Beauty despite violence

5 stars

This novel by Ocean Vuong is told from a first-person narrative as an autobiographical story written to the protagonist's mother. But using this as a device, it tells multiple stories simultaneously. Each is almost a parable, and none is independent of another. It takes place in the USA primarily.

The protagonist relates his coming into the world, his childhood, his first love, his violent youth, his grandmother's love for him (and her past life in Vietnam), and his experiences of grief. Entangled are the acts of violence of the Vietnam War, the estrangement of the protagonist from his two nations, drug addiction and abuse, philosophy and thoughts on how words find meaning. The story alone is uncomplicated, and ticks along at a pleasant pace, but the poetic undertones and masterful weaving of story with concept make it a wonderful experience. To paraphrase Vuong's words: This book is not created from …