Reviews and Comments

Phil in SF

kingrat@books.theunseen.city

Joined 2 years, 5 months ago

I have moved my Bookwyrming to @kingrat@sfba.club

This link opens in a pop-up window

The Poison Squad (EBook, 2018, Penguin Press) 4 stars

From Pulitzer Prize winner and New York Times-bestselling author Deborah Blum, the dramatic true story …

Solid history of early food regulation in the US

4 stars

I found myself fascinated by the chapters covering Harvey Wiley's early investigations and efforts. Once the book became about the political machinations after the law was passed, i became less interested. Business applying secret pressure to get regulations eased is a well trod tale

The Poison Squad (EBook, 2018, Penguin Press) 4 stars

From Pulitzer Prize winner and New York Times-bestselling author Deborah Blum, the dramatic true story …

After 20+ years of advocacy Harvey Wiley sees the Pure Food and Drug Act. Upton Sinclair's The Jungle was published widely just before, though apparently it omitted a pro socialism ending that had been present in the original serial.

Die Trying (EBook, 2006, Jove) 3 stars

Jack Reacher, alone, strolling nowhere. A Chicago street in bright sunshine. A young woman, struggling …

Pure Jason Bourne style action

3 stars

Content warning Spoilers, mild

Die Trying (EBook, 2006, Jove) 3 stars

Jack Reacher, alone, strolling nowhere. A Chicago street in bright sunshine. A young woman, struggling …

This is only the second Jack Reacher novel I've picked up, so maybe this changes in the future. But I really enjoy that there's no real sense of danger. Jack Reacher is such an über competent badass that I know he's not going to get more than a scratch. It means the story is not really allowed to have possibility, but I'm in the mood for a predictable story.

The Echo Wife (Paperback, 2022, Tor Books) 5 stars

Best book I've read in ages

5 stars

Easily the most engrossing book I've read in a long time. Take science fiction (cloning) and mix it with domestic suspense (murder!) into a very compelling and original plot. Rather than presenting the reader with a babyface and heels, the book has complex characters that lean toward mean because they come from damaging backgrounds. And while I didn't want to root for them, the story drew me in to where I wanted to see everyone have a satisfying end, rather than get what they deserved.

The background of these characters makes the story extremely layered and rich, but a warning. As the author writes in their acknowledgements, The Echo Wife is about abuse, grooming and identity. My abuse was long enough ago, and my psyche is hard to damage these days. The specific situations described are also dissimilar enough from what I faced that I did not have trouble with …

The Echo Wife (Paperback, 2022, Tor Books) 5 stars

Content warning Mild spoiler