Blackberry Jim reviewed The Devil in the Marshalsea by Antonia Hodgson
A well-researched thriller!
4 stars
A friend gave this to me with a strong recommendation a while ago. I really enjoyed this - great attention to historical detail without it feeling at all like the author was shoehorning things in, resulting in a wonderful sense of atmosphere and plausibility. It didn't shy away from some difficult topics, and not from over-confidence, I think. A real range of well-drawn characters and a great sense of the narrator's own personality, and what that conceals about the world he lives in. Hodgson made this rude libertine a likeable and entertaining main character without making him not Really a libertine, which is really an accomplishment. I felt like the habitual sexism of the main character's internal narration Did actually add to the story's verisimilitude, which is pretty rare for me.
Spoilers below!
o
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
- The conclusion to the murder didn't feel …
A friend gave this to me with a strong recommendation a while ago. I really enjoyed this - great attention to historical detail without it feeling at all like the author was shoehorning things in, resulting in a wonderful sense of atmosphere and plausibility. It didn't shy away from some difficult topics, and not from over-confidence, I think. A real range of well-drawn characters and a great sense of the narrator's own personality, and what that conceals about the world he lives in. Hodgson made this rude libertine a likeable and entertaining main character without making him not Really a libertine, which is really an accomplishment. I felt like the habitual sexism of the main character's internal narration Did actually add to the story's verisimilitude, which is pretty rare for me.
Spoilers below!
o
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
- The conclusion to the murder didn't feel so exciting because they did such a thorough job of showing you how to rule everyone out, and maybe it's just because the mindset is so alien but the motive didn't feel like an 'oh, I see it now!!' kind of thing. Wasn't quite contrived though. I did like how the conclusion continued beyond the frame he'd been set in by Charles & Sir Philip and showed the beginnings of different lives afterward!