Reviews and Comments

None

ingrid@bookwyrm.social

Joined 3 years, 11 months ago

This link opens in a pop-up window

The Terraformers (Hardcover, 2023, Tor Books) 4 stars

From science fiction visionary Annalee Newitz comes The Terraformers, a sweeping, uplifting, and illuminating exploration …

Fun and provocative, but this felt like it should have been a trilogy and unfortunately got squished into a single volume. Kim Stanley Robinson blurbed this and is thanked in the acknowledgments, so I don't feel totally dismissive of Newitz's efforts when noting that the influence of the Mars Trilogy is pretty apparent in this epic planetary narrative. But Newitz only gets like 350 pages to create their centuries-spanning world, compared to KSR's set of tomes, and it at times I felt a little rushed along. I wanted to have more time with some of the characters and the political economy.

I love that one of the central characters is a sentient organic flying train though, that's great. Also minor spoiler, the train fucks!

The Immortal King Rao (Hardcover, 2022, W.W. Norton & Company) No rating

In an Indian village in the 1950s, a precocious child is born into a family …

Pretty good although I found the tech dystopia part a little simplistic and I kind of wanted more detail on Rao's apparent brilliance to make the meteoric rise seem less fable-ish--e.g. we're told he's really good at writing code and making new programming languages but we don't really get any insight into what coding is like for him or what's unique about his languages. If the idea is that he's kind of a Steve Jobs-ian charlatan who isn't actually that good at stuff and the lesson is the happenstance of capitalism, would also like more evidence to support that framing!

Upgrade (Hardcover, 2022, Ballantine Books) 3 stars

“You are the next step in human evolution.”

At first, Logan Ramsay isn’t sure if …

Content warning mild spoilers but also I didn't like it so who cares

Palo Alto (2023, Little Brown & Company) 3 stars

Palo Alto’s weather is temperate, its people are educated and enterprising, its corporations are spiritually …

Overall: a valuable contribution to contextualizing the miasma of historical developments generally shorthanded as "tech", and I also hope far from the final word on any of its subjects. The pandemic meant that Harris took a largely desk-research approach to writing this book and while it is voluminously footnoted, it's not based in archival research or extensive interviews. This is fine for what Harris is trying to do, which is very much a big world-systems analysis, but it also means there are some things he sort of glosses in ways that historians will probably find annoying.

As someone who grew up in this part of California I do wish it had hewed its narrative more explicitly to Palo Alto/the peninsula of the Bay Area as a place--most readers won't miss the absence of niche local detail but some of the strongest parts of the book are the ones that ground …