Reviews and Comments

loppear

loppear@bookwyrm.social

Joined 4 years, 1 month ago

Reading for fun, threads over the years of scifi, history, social movements and justice, farming, philosophy. I actively work to balance out the white male default in what I read, but have a long way to go.

He/they for the praxis.

This link opens in a pop-up window

reviewed Blind Spots by Marty Makary

Blind Spots (2024, Bloomsbury Publishing USA) 2 stars

deeply undermines itself

2 stars

Clear thesis that medicine by opinion and reputation-driven dogma harms us rather than saying "we don't know" and seeking evidence in basic research. Chapter case studies of past opinion-driven tragedies - infant peanut allergy guidelines, discouraging hormone replacement therapy, low-fat low cholesterol diet for heart health, blood bank testing for HIV - are presented with institutional context and evidence, while other case studies may be less supported. However, rather than solid advice for evaluating evidence or identifying opinion, or cases of time-tested evidence in scientific medicine, Makarty tragically switches to offering his own declared opinions about what may or may not be "dogma" to be overturned ahead, all with a nod to the "do your own research" crowd he's adopted, including fluoride, gender-affirming care, and covid immunity. What to do about trust in medical consensus and basic research is set aside, leaving us scared and blind towards the future, though …

The Sentence (Hardcover, 2021, Harper) 4 stars

Louise Erdrich's latest novel, The Sentence, asks what we owe to the living, the dead, …

A good 2020 book, positively and darkly

4 stars

An unsteady book, wherever you may stumble in reading it I can at least say it was about to turn a corner to something else quirky unexpected and real, and the bulk of the story is true enough and heartfelt as far as I can recall and relate, a 2020 Covid & George Floyd indigenous bookstore memoir for Minneapolis.

Playground (2024, Norton & Company, Incorporated, W. W.) 2 stars

Four lives are drawn together in a sweeping, panoramic new novel from Richard Powers, showcasing …

disappointment

2 stars

While full of a sense of wonder (of other-than-human and human capacities) and social inequality (wealth and the access and control that exerts over the world and our relationships), this turned out to be a story I deeply do not care about, narratively driven by what I'll call in mild spoiler a Thiel-inflected AI.

Stardust Grail (2024, Flatiron Books) 3 stars

Save one world. Doom her own.

From the acclaimed author of The Deep Sky comes …

inventive riffs on so many scales of space adventure

3 stars

A delightful heist buddy crew against the odds space marines aliens in all configurations inscrutable galactic menace histories of oppression misunderstanding and hope. Also, a bit light and scattered.

Rose/House (EBook, Subterranean Press) 4 stars

Basit Deniau’s houses were haunted to begin with.

A house embedded with an artificial intelligence …

As spare translucent noir, I enjoyed it.

3 stars

Each element is pristine and sun-baked here, like the setting: reluctant detective on the murder case, wealthy aesthetic recluse, mundanely dystopian AI. And as spare translucent noir, I enjoyed it.

The Warm Hands of Ghosts (Hardcover, 2024, Del Rey) 4 stars

During the Great War, a combat nurse searches for her brother, believed dead in the …

Heartwrenching horrors of WWI

4 stars

Compelled to return to the frontlines of madness, clawing for oblivion in the face of evils and devils, a glint of compassion and sanity from another human sharing the experience. Deftly haunting storytelling.

Deacon King Kong (2020, Riverhead Books, an imprint of Penguin Random House LLC) 4 stars

the audiobook is an absorbing performance

4 stars

What a delightful sprawling madcap slice of New York. Dark and funny, an overwhelming cast and set of threads and diversions. Did any of it matter? Does it voice a rosy cozy gritty 60s or grimly stubborn mid-point between southern oppression and modern violence of drugs and poverty? As recommended to me, the audiobook is an absorbing performance.

Resisting Garbage (2021, University of Texas Press) 3 stars

Resisting Garbage presents a new approach to understanding practices of waste removal and recycling in …

how slowly public reframing of infrastructure makes incremental changes possible

3 stars

Wasteways and waste regimes, this points to larger intersectional issues of production, consumption, and political-institutional capture - but is primarily a close comparison of waste management policy in Boston & Seattle in the 1980s and 90s, focused on ultimately narrow variations in recycling programs and citizen input, and how those are compliant or resistant to our national narrative of trash.