Parts of this were overwhelming (mostly grief), parts of it dull (so much battle strategy). I adored Hild, I'm happy to see more of her, and I didn't thrill to this as much as I wanted.
Reviews and Comments
dorking around with old books for work and reading new(ish) books for fun with strong opinions but an inconsistent rating system | you can find me most places as wynkenhimself including as @wynkenhimself@glammr.us | she/her
This link opens in a pop-up window
sarah reviewed Menewood by Nicola Griffith
sarah reviewed Sea of Tranquility by Emily St. John Mandel
sarah reviewed Burial Rites by Hannah Kent
sarah reviewed A Distant Grave by Sarah Stewart Taylor
sarah reviewed No fond return of love by Barbara Pym
even better as a reread
5 stars
reread this for my book club and it's just really great. the details! the shifting point of views and sympathy for the characters (who still drive me nuts). and it's even better if you think about indexing while reading it--why is Dulcie an indexer and what is that telling us about the gender and love plots? anyway. it's great.
sarah reviewed Translation State by Ann Leckie
sarah reviewed Moby-Dick by Herman Melville
the weirdest wildest thing and can't wait to reread
5 stars
I did it! I finished reading Moby-Dick, a book I discovered in grad school for the 50-book exam (Penn's weird version of comps, which is even weirder because the year my cohort took it, it was more like 75 books and we were the only group subject to what every agrees was a mammoth failure of a list) and of which I only read a handful of chapters because who has the time to read the whole thing when we also had to read Leaves of Grass, Little Dorrit, Canterbury Tales (maybe all?), Emily Dickinson (all), Middlemarch, Ulysess, and so much more? But I loved those few chapters and have meant for decades to go back and read the whole thing and finally, inspired by Hester Blum's new edition and my trip to New Zealand, I started in on it for real in December 2022 and have been slowly working …
I did it! I finished reading Moby-Dick, a book I discovered in grad school for the 50-book exam (Penn's weird version of comps, which is even weirder because the year my cohort took it, it was more like 75 books and we were the only group subject to what every agrees was a mammoth failure of a list) and of which I only read a handful of chapters because who has the time to read the whole thing when we also had to read Leaves of Grass, Little Dorrit, Canterbury Tales (maybe all?), Emily Dickinson (all), Middlemarch, Ulysess, and so much more? But I loved those few chapters and have meant for decades to go back and read the whole thing and finally, inspired by Hester Blum's new edition and my trip to New Zealand, I started in on it for real in December 2022 and have been slowly working my way through since. It is a hella weird book, so much more weird than I was expecting. I read a lot of it while on planes and while stoned in bed, so that may have shaped my reaction, but it's actually a great way to read this, where you just kind of zoom in on the language that's right in front of you and lose track of the plot and big picture. And is there a plot here? I mean there is, but it's not really the point. Anyway. I still don't know how to think about this book, but I'm so glad I read it. And I am still always thinking about it
sarah reviewed The Mountains Wild by Sarah Stewart Taylor
sarah reviewed The Dictionary of Lost Words by Pip Williams
wow didacticism
3 stars
Loved the premise, but this should have been so much better than this didactic slog with featureless characters. Victoire's defining characteristic? Born in Haiti. Does she have a personality? Who knows! I'm cranky and can't believe I dragged through this. YMMV! But I felt about this the way Amal El-Mohtar did in her review of Yellowface.
sarah reviewed Behind the Scenes by Karelia Stetz-Waters
fun queer romance
4 stars
A good queer romance, although I'm positive the way it describes movie making and funding is bonkers. Like her Satisfaction Guaranteed, very good on anxieties around sex and kind ways of healing, so more than worth suspending disbelief about movieland.
sarah reviewed Less Is Lost by Andrew Sean Greer
sarah reviewed Endpapers by Jennifer Savran Kelly
sarah reviewed Binding by Bridget Collins
oof it made me angry
3 stars
There are good things about this! But also, at its core, there's a disdain and self-hatred about novels and writing that makes me furious. I read this with #BookishBookClub otherwise I probably would have stopped, but we did have a good discussion!