Reviews and Comments

From my blog :
Saladin Ahmed’s debut fiction, a Nebula award nominated work enthralls the reader from the word go. It follows a group of well-wishers of a kingdom fight against a great and powerful enemy that the main protagonist Adoulla a ghul hunter has never come across before. The novel, although it screams ‘Sword and Sorcery’ is in itself more than that. The book does have it’s share of sword fightings, blood and incidents that would make any brave soul cringe, but the portrayal bequeathes from the genre-type to one that dwells to human meta-physical sense. It speaks about each member’s stance in face of hardship, their choices, their inner battles and the ill-fated bargains they do with negative emotions to reach their goal.

The other important characters are Adoulla’s dervish, Raseed bas Raseed, the tribeswoman and guard of her band, Zamia, an Alchemist and her husband who is Adoulla’s long time friend and the Falcon prince who strives to balance out the divide between the rich and the poor while plotting to kill the iron-fisted Khalif and rule the kingdom himself. The book is heavy on theism and Islamic connotations, which would do good to change the minds of the ignorant who have been brainwashed by fear-mongers to consider Islam being a religion of extremism. The book itself talks about extremist with hope and moderate with experience and calculated approach, and the chemistry between the doctor as the main-protagonist is referred as, and his young dervish is told in well structured manner.

The novel is filled with shape shifters, beautiful ornate castles, water ghuls, fire ghuls, bone ghuls, zombi like skin ghuls which can reform to totality from every shred it’s attackers tore it into, magicians, alchemists and even a part-shadow part-jackal man. The novel fails short in that the story is too straightforward and every story changing incidents end abruptly, but it succeeds in everything else, the buildup and the characterization. The words are decorated with beautiful explanations and Saladin takes our imagination into the city of Dhamsawaat, which is the setting of the book, with ease. I’d like to add I was put down from less view-of-the-plot from other members of the protagonist gang, perhaps the author liked Adoulla very much that he did less with the romance between the young dervish and the bandit fighter, that I’d have liked to read. And to save the best to last, it was highly refreshing to have a setting far from European Medieval into a Muslim, where currency is dinar, and you would kneel placing your forehead over the foot of your lover to ask her to wed.

If its been just days after devouring some Joe Abercrombie or Patrick Rothfuss fast paced books, you might be in for some scour from the initial chapters, but once you get a hang of the writing, you are in for the thrill that is the concluding chapters. I was so engrossed that I turend around 40 pages in 15 minutes, which is a record for not-so-fast reader like me, especially considering the high level of language the novel is dispersed with.

Not to be missed, a book that stands by itself, great debut and first in a planned trilogy. The short 288 page fantasy book sticks to you far more than 600 pagers his peers put out every year.

Footnote : Once you are done with the book you might consider the prequel and Adoulla’s introduction in the short story Where Virtue Lives.

“There’s a lot of science fiction that talks about the near future. There’s a lot about great galaxy-spanning empires of the distant future. But there’s not much that talks about the part in between. The Expanse is playing on that bridge” – authors’ reply to the question of ‘What kind of story are you telling in this series’.

Written under the pen name James S. A. Corey-a collaboration between fantasy author Daniel Abraham and Ty Franck, the story revolves around two men Holden and Miller andImage - Leviathan Wakes their rising-above-human decisions that averts a catastrophe. Two men totally opposite in character, the former a ship’s pilot and the latter a tired and aging criminal detective. The men are similar in that they are solution-driven, in that they’d do anything ranging from lying-to governments, to the guiding systems of missiles and even to self-driven rocks to intimidation, extortion, to get the job done.The similarities end there. This big book is about everything that comprises our solar system, including the meta-physical.

The book is two-faced, chapters divided between Holden’s experiences and Miller’s. The former’s is fast-paced, full of incidents and action, while the latter’s is noir’ish.

Miller sets out to bring home a kidnapped daughter of a wealthy empire so she could forget her personal dreams and do what is best for her family but ends up seeing her having been devoured by something alien to mankind. Holden faces loss in form of his ship and team members and sets out to avenge it.
How these two come into contact, understand the inner political workings, discover something totally bizzare and huge and thwart an end-of-humanity incident is what this book is about. It tries being an hard sci-fi but the latter half of the book, particularly the end throws the impression away.

Written by authors one of who’s name always gets followed with being ‘George R. R. Martin’s assistant, I can understand the scope of story includes meta-physical contacts and inter-species conversations, arguments and bargaining, but can’t say I buy it. It was a great ride and I’d like to stop by saying I thoroughly enjoyed it. The writing is excellent and it felt I was eating a sweet moist cake that I could go on devouring for hours together without getting stressed. To the ‘Caliban’s war’ I go.