Joshua Byrd reviewed 1Q84 by Haruki Murakami
Review of '1Q84' on 'Goodreads'
5 stars
A work of brilliance.
925 pages
English language
Published May 9, 2011
1Q84
2 stars
(3 reviews)
1Q84 (いちきゅうはちよん, Ichi-Kyū-Hachi-Yon, stylized in the Japanese cover as "ichi-kew-hachi-yon") is a novel written by Japanese writer Haruki Murakami, first published in three volumes in Japan in 2009–10. It covers a fictionalized year of 1984 in parallel with a "real" one. The novel is a story of how a woman named Aomame begins to notice strange changes occurring in the world. She is quickly caught up in a plot involving Sakigake, a religious cult, and her childhood love, Tengo, and embarks on a journey to discover what is "real". The novel's first printing sold out on the day it was released and sales reached a million within a month. The English-language edition of all three volumes, with the first two volumes translated by Jay Rubin and the third by Philip Gabriel, was released in North America and the United Kingdom on October 25, 2011. An excerpt from the novel appeared …
1Q84 (いちきゅうはちよん, Ichi-Kyū-Hachi-Yon, stylized in the Japanese cover as "ichi-kew-hachi-yon") is a novel written by Japanese writer Haruki Murakami, first published in three volumes in Japan in 2009–10. It covers a fictionalized year of 1984 in parallel with a "real" one. The novel is a story of how a woman named Aomame begins to notice strange changes occurring in the world. She is quickly caught up in a plot involving Sakigake, a religious cult, and her childhood love, Tengo, and embarks on a journey to discover what is "real". The novel's first printing sold out on the day it was released and sales reached a million within a month. The English-language edition of all three volumes, with the first two volumes translated by Jay Rubin and the third by Philip Gabriel, was released in North America and the United Kingdom on October 25, 2011. An excerpt from the novel appeared in the September 5, 2011 issue of The New Yorker magazine as "Town of Cats". The first chapter of 1Q84 had also been read as an excerpt in the Selected Shorts series at Symphony Space in New York. While well received in Japan, 1Q84 was met with mixed to negative reviews from international critics, who condemned the novel's excessive repetition, clichéd writing, clumsy styling and unyielding plot. Literary Review nominated a poorly written excerpt in the book for its annual Bad Sex in Fiction Award.
Dan Jones reviewed 1Q84 by Haruki Murakami
Review of '1Q84' on 'Goodreads'
No rating
I really liked the structure of the book, with alternating limited third person narration (alternating between the two protagonists), but it became confusing towards the end because the limited perspective kept bouncing around from paragraph to paragraph, rather than chapter to chapter, as was initially established. This shift in narrative format took me somewhat out of the story.
Although, by that time, it became clear that this novel is more of a romance than anything else, which took me out of the story anyway, as romances hold less interest for me.
Most of the book was fairly interesting, but not among my favorites, for sure.
